The IPCC’s Sixth Assessment Report stopped calling every change in the climate a hazard. It introduced climatic impact-drivers: physical climate conditions that affect a system, and that can be harmful, helpful or neutral depending on the system. For anyone running a risk assessment, the change is practical.
What a climatic impact-driver is
Working Group I defines 33 climatic impact-drivers (CIDs) in seven groups: heat and cold; wet and dry; wind; snow and ice; coastal; open ocean; and other, which covers air-pollution weather, atmospheric CO2 and radiation at the surface. A CID is a hazard only when its consequence for a specific system is adverse. Warmer summers lengthen the growing season on a farm but deepen the thaw under a permafrost embankment: the same change has different consequences for different systems.
Why it helps an assessment
The framework forces the right order of questions: which system, then which CID, then which index and threshold. It also works as a checklist. Assessments that start from a familiar list of hazards tend to miss the ones that do not make headlines: freezing rain and ice accretion, rain on snow, freeze-thaw cycles, compound events such as heat with drought. Walking the seven CID groups at the scoping workshop catches them.
From driver to index to threshold
Each CID is measured by one or more indices, and each index is tested against a threshold that comes from the asset or the operation. Heat: days above 30 °C, heatwave length, cooling degree days. Wet: the heaviest day of rain, the 1-in-100-year 24-hour total. Snow and ice: freezing degree days, freeze-thaw cycles, the 50-year ice-accretion load. The threshold is where the engineering and the operations staff come in, and it is why the climate analysis should be scoped with them in the room.
Direction and magnitude are two different confidences
AR6 reports, by region, how confident the science is that each CID is changing in a given direction. Confidence in the size of the change is often lower, especially for sub-daily rainfall, freezing rain and wind. A sound assessment carries both into the likelihood score: where direction is confident but magnitude is not, it scores likelihood from the range across the model ensemble and says so, rather than reporting a single number as if it were settled.
How we use it
Our assessments organize hazards by CID group, from the territory-wide work in Nunavut (temperature change, wet conditions, dry conditions, wind and stormy weather, snow and ice, coastal conditions) to asset portfolios in Ontario and water infrastructure in Iraq. The structure means a council, an engineer and a climate scientist are looking at the same list, and nothing that matters to the assets in scope is left off it by habit.
A CID checklist for your scoping workshop
- Heat and cold: means, extremes, degree days, frost
- Wet and dry: mean and heavy precipitation, drought, aridity, fire weather
- Wind: mean and extreme wind, storms
- Snow and ice: snow, freezing rain and ice accretion, permafrost, lake and river ice
- Coastal and lake: water levels, surge, erosion
- Compound events: heat with drought, rain on snow, wind with ice
- Opportunities as well as hazards, named as such
Used this way, the framework replaces a debate about which hazards to include with a list that everyone in the room can see.
Sources
- IPCC AR6 Working Group I, Chapter 12: Climate change information for regional impact and for risk assessment
- Ruane et al. (2022), The Climatic Impact-Driver Framework for assessment of risk-relevant climate information, Earth’s Future
- IPCC WGI Interactive Atlas
- ISO 14091:2021, Adaptation to climate change: guidelines on vulnerability, impacts and risk assessment
