Independent expert evidence
Expert opinions and litigation support
Independent, evidence-based opinions on weather, climate and water, for courts, tribunals and insurers.

Why the science matters in a dispute
Our scientific experts provide practical, evidence-informed, unbiased and independent opinions to support legal proceedings.
There is a wide range of circumstances in which an independent expert opinion is required, and each requires specialist knowledge and the application of specific skills.
It is now unequivocal that human activities are changing the climate, and this shapes important decisions about the structure of economies, human development and natural resource use. Engineering and environmental design often have to be balanced against the sustainability of the ecosystems on which people and biodiversity depend, and the conflict between economic growth and the environment is complex and sharper today than ever before. Across federal, provincial and territorial governments and Indigenous communities, environmental regulations and compliance enforcement strategies are in place to manage carbon dioxide emissions, pollution, biodiversity loss, water security and waste, with the aim of minimizing impacts on health and the environment.
More extreme weather and climate events are expected as the climate continues to change. The frequency, intensity and timing of events are changing, while slow-onset changes may lead to fundamental transformation of socio-economic systems. Recent extreme events in Canada have shown what continued climate change might mean for operational decision-making across the country: floods affecting water management and road systems, permafrost thaw threatening the integrity of buildings, and extreme storms inundating coastlines and disrupting essential services.
Drawing on extensive knowledge and expertise, our scientists provide research and development, expert science assessment and analysis, and support for policy and operational decisions in a range of sectors, for investment decisions and legal proceedings.
When a case turns on how much rain fell, how rare a flood was or whether a climate risk was foreseeable, the answer has to rest on data that someone else can check. Dr. Elvis Asong, a hydroclimatologist with more than 16 years in climate, meteorological and hydrological science, provides independent expert opinions and the analysis behind them.
Weather and water are at issue in many disputes: a flooded basement or subdivision, an overwhelmed culvert, storm sewer or spillway, runoff from a neighbouring development that damages land, construction weeks lost to rain and cold, or a disagreement between an insurer and a policyholder about whether a storm was exceptional. As the climate changes, events once treated as rare happen more often, and questions about what owners, designers and governments knew, and when, are asked more often too.
Answering these questions means reconstructing what the records show, how the event compares with the design standard in force at the time, and how confident a conclusion can be with the data that exist.
Questions we answer
- How much rain or snow fell, when and where, including at sites with no weather station.
- How rare an event was: its return period against the IDF curves and design standards in force at the time.
- Whether a drainage system, culvert, storm sewer or spillway met the design standard for the event it experienced.
- How runoff and drainage changed after construction, grading or a change in land use, and whether it reached neighbouring property.
- What a past flood looked like: peak flows and water levels reconstructed from gauge records, high-water evidence and hydrological modelling.
- Weather on construction projects: days lost to rain, wind, heat or cold compared with the climate normals for the site.
- Freezing rain, snow, wind and heat events behind insurance claims or infrastructure failures.
- Whether a flood or drought was foreseeable from the climate data and trends known at the time.
- Whether, and by how much, climate change made an event more likely or more intense (extreme event attribution).
- Future flood and drought risk: what climate change means for a property, an asset or a water licence.
- Water supply and flood mitigation: allocation, reservoir operation, and agricultural runoff and drainage.
- Environmental flows: how much water a river needs, and the effect of withdrawals or regulation.
- Whether a climate risk assessment, adaptation plan or emissions claim followed recognized methods such as ISO 14091, the PIEVC Protocol and IPCC guidance.
What we provide
- Preliminary assessment. An early, candid view of what the data can and cannot show, before a full report is commissioned.
- Expert reports. Independent reports that set out qualifications, the questions asked, the data, methods, assumptions, findings and their uncertainty, prepared to the expert evidence rules of the court or tribunal, such as Ontario’s Rule 53.03 and the Federal Courts’ Code of Conduct for Expert Witnesses.
- Review of other experts’ reports. A technical critique of another expert’s data, methods and conclusions, and questions for counsel.
- Data recovery and preservation. Station, reanalysis, radar and streamflow records retrieved and documented so the analysis can be reproduced.
- Testimony. Evidence at discovery, hearings, arbitration and trial, explained in plain language.
- Joint expert meetings and mediation support. Narrowing the technical issues with the other side’s expert.
How we work
- Independent. The opinion follows the evidence. An expert’s duty is to the court or tribunal, not to the party that retains them, as the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed in White Burgess Langille Inman v. Abbott and Haliburton Co. (2015 SCC 23). Our fees never depend on the outcome.
- Conflict-checked. Every engagement starts with a conflict check.
- Reproducible. Every number traces to a named dataset and a documented method; data and code can be shared with the other side’s expert when required.
- Confidential. We do not publish client names or case details.
- Plain language. Findings a judge, arbitrator or adjuster can follow, with the technical appendix behind them.
Data and methods
We choose the data and methods that fit the question, such as:
- Observations. Weather and streamflow records such as Environment and Climate Change Canada stations (including adjusted and homogenized series), provincial and municipal networks, and Water Survey of Canada gauges.
- Gridded and reanalysis data. Products such as ERA5 and ERA5-Land, the Canadian Precipitation Analysis (CaPA) and Canadian Surface Reanalysis (CaSR), satellite precipitation and archived radar.
- Frequency analysis. Extreme value methods such as GEV distributions, IDF analysis and non-stationary approaches.
- Extreme event attribution. Approaches such as probabilistic and storyline attribution, using observations and climate model ensembles, with the limits of the evidence stated.
- Hydrological and runoff modelling. Models such as CRHM, Raven and MESH, and event-based runoff methods.
- Climate projections. Ensembles such as CMIP6, downscaled and bias-corrected, with the uncertainty stated.
Qualifications
- Ph.D. Hydroclimatology, University of Saskatchewan (Best Doctoral Thesis in Water Security Research); M.Sc. Water Resources Engineering, Lund University.
- More than 16 years of climate, meteorological and hydrological analysis for governments, utilities, industry and international programs.
- Expert Reviewer, IPCC Sixth Assessment Report; Adjunct Professor, Global Institute for Water Security, University of Saskatchewan.
- Peer-reviewed research on precipitation modelling, drought, extremes and cold-region hydrology; reviewer for more than 20 journals.
- Author and instructor of CLIM095 Applied Climate Science for Infrastructure Practitioners (Climate Risk Institute and Royal Roads University).
See Dr. Elvis Asong’s full profile and our research.
Who retains us
Law firms acting for plaintiffs or defendants, insurers and adjusters, municipalities and utilities, developers and contractors, and governments and regulators.
Related: Weather, meteorology and climate baselines · Design values for extremes · Hydrological monitoring, modelling and simulation · Hydro-meteorological forecasting · All services
Request an expert opinion
Send the question, the location and the dates. We will tell you what the data can answer, usually within two working days, before any engagement begins.
